anxiety

Managing a Difficult Manager

Individuals do not leave unsatisfying jobs; instead, they flee unsupportive leaders.

Naomi found herself plagued by reoccurring nightmares where she was stuck in a dim parking lot, attempting to evade approaching footsteps. Each time, a shadowy figure with a recognizable face drew near, causing Naomi to feel paralyzed. Upon awakening, she was soaked in sweat.

With the help of therapy and coaching, Naomi connected the dots between her nightmares and her overbearing boss. She came to understand that the constant anxiety she experienced before work originated from his demanding demeanor. Despite his push for heightened performance, his methods eroded her confidence and impeded her effectiveness.

Workplace stress due to challenging managers is more widespread than commonly acknowledged. Confronting managers who misbehave, establish unattainable standards, or lack support for work-life balance often leads to adverse health repercussions.

Unhealthy work settings have been associated with increased anxiety, depression, disrupted sleep, elevated blood pressure, and premature aging. Elevated work stress may result in detrimental behaviors and routines, infiltrating personal lives and affecting the well-being of loved ones.

Poor managers manifest in various forms, from narcissists and bullies to micromanagers. Among them are individuals prone to extreme mood swings, unreasonable expectations, information hoarding, conflict avoidance, absence of positive reinforcement, and perpetual unavailability. These characteristics render them challenging to work with.

Particularly detrimental are managers displaying psychopathic and narcissistic traits. Fueled by this “dark dyad,” they often exhibit Machiavellian tendencies, exploiting their subordinates, claiming credit for their work, overly criticizing, and misbehaving. Beyond being a nightmare for individuals, poor managers can severely impact the overall work environment. Their demands and actions deplete employees’ drive and motivation, contribute to mental exhaustion, and impede performance.

Moreover, when managers pit subordinates against one another, a culture of positive competition can devolve into distrust and betrayal. The repercussions are severe: employees may frequently miss work due to mental health challenges, while others may opt to leave their positions to escape their manager.

Strategies for Handling a Challenging Manager

When faced with a manager who intrudes on personal time or expects work sacrifices, it is crucial to recalibrate expectations with the manager or HR department or contemplate alternative career paths. Below are several tactics to consider when dealing with challenging managers.

1. Set Clear Boundaries and Acknowledge Managerial Pressures

A critical initial step is establishing clear boundaries and delineating what is and isn’t feasible. Setting boundaries involves respectfully refusing unrealistic demands. One strategy is to discuss your current workload with your manager and thoroughly discuss realistic objectives and timelines.

Adding to the importance of career development, individuals can benefit greatly from professional career coaching services. Organizations like Your Career Place offer personalized guidance and support to help individuals navigate their career paths more effectively. Through one-on-one sessions, career assessments, and tailored action plans, career coaches can assist individuals in setting and achieving their career goals. Investing in professional career coaching can lead to increased job satisfaction, improved performance, and enhanced workplace advancement opportunities.

Simultaneously, use this dialogue as an opportunity to understand your manager’s pressures. This comprehension may facilitate aligning expectations and identifying mutually beneficial solutions. Through this process, you might discover that your manager is less challenging than initially perceived.

2. Offer Constructive Feedback on the Leadership Approach

If boundary setting proves ineffective and you remain overwhelmed, it might be time to address your manager’s leadership style directly. However, vocalizing your frustrations necessitates a delicate approach. Challenging a complex manager may entail confronting those who appointed them and urging them to address the dysfunctional behavior—a task they may be hesitant to undertake.

Should you opt for this conversation, consider enlisting HR’s assistance and involving them in the dialogue. To secure their backing, build a case demonstrating the impact of your manager’s behavior on your mental health and that of other team members, ultimately affecting overall performance. When broaching this subject, provide detailed documentation of your manager’s problematic conduct, highlighting the issues and presenting constructive suggestions for improvement.

3. Transition Gracefully to a Different Role

If your manager remains unyielding or unwilling to change, and you enjoy your organization but find your current role untenable, exploring internal opportunities is an option. Consider pursuing a lateral shift, though this necessitates robust networking efforts. Begin subtly signaling to senior executives your openness to new roles and eagerness to take on broader responsibilities.

While engaging in networking endeavors, refrain from disparaging your manager or engaging in office gossip. Avoiding confrontation is advisable; instead, focus on spotlighting your strengths and achievements.

4. Seek New Employment with a More Supportive Supervisor

If your current job continues to negatively impact your health and well-being with no prospects for change or reassignment, it may be time to explore new career prospects. Identify a work environment that values your skills rather than hoping for improvement in your relationship with your challenging manager.

Expanding your professional network and gaining insights into potential career pathways may reveal organizations seeking your expertise. However, exercise caution to prevent finding yourself in a situation akin to your previous experience. Avoid a repeat of the same challenges by conducting thorough due diligence.

5. Leverage Support and Reevaluate Career Choices

Prioritizing your mental well-being is crucial for leading a fulfilling life. Everyone requires support networks; therefore, if a strained professional relationship is causing stress, it may be time to seek guidance from a coach, mentor, or other trained professional. Such individuals can guide you towards more rewarding career avenues.

Naomi determined that her optimal course of action was to move on. She viewed her experience as a valuable learning opportunity. Ironically, working under a challenging manager honed her managerial skills and imparted lessons on avoiding replicating similar behavior.

Given the substantial time spent at work, professional environments should not jeopardize mental or physical health. Individuals who are mentally sound can maximize their potential, navigate life’s challenges, and contribute meaningfully. At work, everyone deserves respect and equitable treatment; no one should compromise their mental well-being for a toxic job.

Thank you for stopping by Your Career Place. We are excited to help you navigate your career journey. 

Related articles from your friends at Your Career Place.

https://yourcareerplace.com/lifestyle/transform-your-health-with-these-12-easy-habit-adjustments